|
Victoria:
Orcas under attack
By Tara Carman
Victoria Weekend Edition
June 18, 2004
Every year, tens of thousands of people
in Victoria pay upward of $60 each to catch a glimpse of one of B.C.'s
most majestic and unique natural phenomena - the killer whale. No
symbol resonates so profoundly with coastal British Columbians. Proof
can be found on the streets of downtown Victoria - now featuring
brightly-painted replicas of the mammal. The orca has figured
prominently in Haida spirituality and artwork for centuries and today
forms the logo of the Vancouver Canucks.

Yet, this much-revered animal is now
among the most polluted mammals in the world. A 2000 Institute of
Ocean Sciences study found that PCB levels in these orcas are almost
five times the level considered by Environment Canada to be toxic
waste. New evidence suggests that what we're pouring into the ocean is
to blame.
As any seasoned whale-watcher will
attest, May through August is the best time to see killer whales. This
is when the three resident pods of orcas spend the most time in the
waters off Victoria and the San Juan Islands.
During this period, Victoria-based commercial whale watching companies
amass gross revenues of about $11 million. That translates into about
$130,000 per whale. Tourists who might not otherwise visit Victoria
come to catch a glimpse of the wild creatures, inadvertently
supporting hundreds of tourism jobs. Luna and Springer aside, the
orcas themselves come without maintenance costs. They are wild
animals, which adds greatly to their appeal.
So what is really happening to these
whales?
The southern resident community, the
technical name for the group of orcas that frequent the waters around
southern Vancouver Island, is only just beginning to recover after a
sharp drop in numbers that had ecologists fearful for their survival.
According to Fisheries and Oceans Canada, the population fell from to
78 whales in 2001 from 99 in 1996 . The most recent count is 83
animals.
A 2004 report by Fisheries and Oceans
Canada warns that the millions of kilograms of pesticides consumed
each year by British Columbians could be harming these animals. Dr.
Peter Ross of the Institute of Ocean Scientists co-authored the study,
which shows that between 1991 and 1999, the quantity of pesticides
sold or used in B.C. increased by 19 per cent to more than eight
million kilograms per year. That's in addition to the chemicals
seeping into the whales' habitat from Puget Sound.
Ross says that PCB contamination is
still a major concern despite the fact that the chemicals were banned
in Canada in the 1970s. PCBs were once widely used in industry, and
thought to be wonder chemicals because of their resilience. But they
are toxic, and can persist in ecosystems for decades.
"We're being haunted by the mistakes of
our past," Ross said in a telephone interview.
Environment Canada requires that any material containing more than 50
parts per million of PCBs be treated as toxic waste. Yet the 2000
study found that the average male transient killer whale contained 250
ppm of PCBs.
Transient orcas are genetically distinct
from residents, and only occasionally pass by Vancouver Island.
Contamination levels are higher in transients because they feed on
marine mammals. Resident male orcas, salmon-eaters, contained on
average 145 ppm. The levels were lower in females, who pass the
chemicals on to their offspring through their milk. These levels are
higher than those found in the belugas of the St. Lawrence.
"The southern resident and transient
killer whales of British Columbia can now be considered among the most
contaminated cetaceans in the world," the report said.
PCBs are still used in some parts of the
world. It only takes five to 10 days for an airborne pollutant to
travel from East Asia to the B.C. coastline, Ross said.
Since orcas are at the top of the marine
food chain, they provide telling indicators of the toxin levels in the
environment, said Ross.
"I use marine mammals as sentinels to
provide me with an amplified signal for environmental contaminants
that are persistent, accumulate in food chains and are toxic," he
said. He added that long-term exposure to such chemicals can result in
reproductive impairment, decreased immunity to disease, and skeletal
and neurological abnormalities.
The 2004 study lists 23 chemicals,
mainly pesticides, that Ross says fit his above three conditions, and
could have effects similar to those of PCBs. One of the most common is
2,4-D, which kills dandelions. And use of these chemicals is on the
rise.
"We should have learned the lesson from
PCBs," said Ross. "There's an accumulation of scientific studies that
say these [23] chemicals may well be harmful for marine mammals as
well."
Ross points out that environmental
policies limiting the use of harmful chemicals and the collective
action of concerned citizens have made a big difference in reducing
pollution. But habitat contamination, he adds, is just one of several
potential threats to the orcas. Hunting and communication can be
disrupted by boat engines or military sonar. The abundance and health
of the orcas' main prey, salmon, must also be considered.
"Every way we look at these animals,
they're under seeming assault," Ross said.
The federal Department of Fisheries and
Oceans is responsible for the stewardship of marine mammals, and has
initiated a killer whale recovery plan for the southern resident
orcas.
Ministry spokeswoman Lara Sloan says the
group is conducting research and consultations with local communities
and experts to determine what is critical habitat and what policies
can be put in place to protect the whales. A report is expected in the
fall.
© Copyright 2004 Victoria
Weekend Edition
|